Close

Donate today to keep Global Voices strong!

Watch the video: We Are Global Voices!

We report on 167 countries. We translate in 35 languages. We are Global Voices. Watch the video »

Over 800 of us from all over the world work together to bring you stories that are hard to find by yourself. But we can’t do it alone. Even though most of us are volunteers, we still need your help to support our editors, our technology, outreach and advocacy projects, and our community events.

Donate now »
GlobalVoices in Learn more »

Referendum on Taiwan's Fourth Nuclear Plant Suspended

Under the immense pressure from anti-nuclear activists, the lawmakers from the ruling Kuomingtang (KMT) party and opposition party the Democratic Progressive Party (DPP) decided to suspend moving forward with a referendum on the island's fourth nuclear power plant until September 2013, according to local news report on August 6.

The ruling party was determined to solve the controversy over the fourth nuclear plant by means of a referendum because opinion back in February showed that those opposed to the plant were less than 50 percent across Taiwan. And hence, the Executive Yuan proposed the referendum on the nuclear power plant on February 25, 2013.

But some argue Taiwan's tough referendum law is unfair, requiring 50 percent of voters to participate in the referendum or else the proposal in the referendum will be rejected, even if those who have voted reach a majority consensus. In the last ten years, six national referendums have been proposed, but none of them was passed.

Anti-nuclear activists responded by mobilizing citizen campaigns in major cities for a nuke-free Taiwan. This latest development is a temporary victory for anti-nuclear activists.

March 9 anti-nuclear rally in Taipei city. Photo taken by 孫窮理, coolloud.org.tw. Non-commercial use.

March 9 anti-nuclear rally in Taipei city. Photo taken by 孫窮理, coolloud.org.tw. Non-commercial use.

Outraged by the government's referendum proposal, on March 9, 2013, around 200,000 250,000 protesters [zh] rallied in Taipei, Taichung, Kaohsiung, and Taitung, demanding the government stop the nuclear plant without going through the referendum. The number of protesters has broken the record of all previous mobilization on environmental issues. The mobilization has some visible effects on public opinion. As cultural critic Chang Tie-chih pointed out, the anti-nuclear effort has developed into a citizen-initiated movement [zh] for a nuke-free Taiwan.

Since the island-wide mobilization in March, anti-nuclear activists has started gathering outside the Chiang Kai-shek Memorial Hall in the centre of Taipei city every Friday, inviting university professors to deliver talks about nuclear power, singers to perform, and poets to recite poetry as well as holding citizen forums to plan for future action. In addition to the weekend face-to-face gathering, activists and concerned citizens created a large number of groups and pages devoted to the anti-nuclear campaign. To name a few here:

Anti-nuclear flash mob via Facebook group Anti-nuclear army

Anti-nuclear flash mob via Facebook group Anti-nuclear army

  • Taiwan Anti-Nuclear Action Coalition (台灣反核行動聯盟) - the page is for organizational networking.
  • 2013 Stop Nukes Now (2013廢核大遊行) - a page for recording and coordinating anti-nuclear protest.
  • Anti-Nuclear Out of Love (為了親愛的你,我反核) - the page collects personal photos that express love and anti-nuclear messages.
  • Coalition of Mothers for the Monitoring of Nuclear Plants (媽媽監督核電廠聯盟) - a page to recruit mothers active against nuclear.
  • Coalition to Determinate the Fourth Nuclear Plant with a Vote (終結核四催票大聯盟) - a page to mobilize Taiwanese to vote in the referendum against the fourth nuclear plant.
  • I Am Human, I Am Against Nuclear (我是人,我反核)- the page coordinates weekend activities against nuclear power.
  • No More Nuke 4 or 5 or 6 in Yilan (宜蘭不要核456運動)- a page devoted to local Yilan mobilization against future nuclear plants.
  • I Am a Dog, I Am Against Nuclear(我是狗,我反核)- a page to remind people that animals and all living creatures are victims of nuclear accidents.
  • Anti-Nuclear Army (反核部隊)- a group for coordinating and sharing anti-nuclear flash mob action.

Disregarding people's wish for a nuke-free Taiwan, on April 26 the government submitted the referendum proposal to the Legislative Yuan for a second reading and lawmakers had one month for internal discussion and negotiation. Anti-nuclear groups responded with a rally in Taipei city on May 19. When the one-month negotiation period came to an end on May 26, activists surrounded the Legislative Yuan [zh], demanding the lawmakers put an end to the nuclear plant project.

On August 2, the referendum proposal was submitted to the Legislative Yuan for a second and third reading but lawmakers from the opposition Democratic Progressive Party occupied the chairperson's stage and stopped the vote.

rotesters demonstrated outside the Legislative Yuan in August 2 against the fourth nuclear plant and the referendum. Photo taken by 陳逸婷, coolloud.org. Non-commercial use.

Protesters demonstrated outside the Legislative Yuan in August 2 against the fourth nuclear plant and the referendum. Photo taken by 陳逸婷, coolloud.org. Non-commercial use.

Anti-nuclear activists are prepared with two strategies. On one front, they protested outside the Legislative Yuan and explained to the public the problem of existing referendum law. On another, they also prepared to mobilize and win the referendum despite the rule of the game being unfair to them. By August 1, a survey conducted by a marketing company on “The Trend of Taiwan Society” [zh] showed that 70% of the opinion is against the development of nuclear plant.

Before the second reading, the Anti-Nuke Action Coalition reinstated their position [zh] against the referendum:

我們認為,停建核四已獲絕大多數民眾的支持,立法院作為全國最高民意機關應善盡職責、充分反映民意,作出停建核四的決議,不必再勞師動眾,舉辦全國性公投。
我們認為國民黨立委若執意要舉辦核四停建公投,則應滿足以下兩個條件後,再處理公投提案,否則,核四停建公投將是玩弄人民、為核四續建備書的技倆:
一、提出核四工程品質現況檢驗報告,證明核四值得投入預算、繼續興建。
二、修正公投法,降低公投案通過之投票率門檻,以正確反映民意。
我們要求立法院在完成上列條件後,再處理核四公投提案,不應貿然在本次臨時會予以表決。
我們呼籲支持非核家園的立委們全力反對核四公投提案之表決。

Considering the majority of the citizens agree on ending construction of the fourth nuclear power plant, the legislators should stop the construction to reflect our opinions and fulfill their duty as our representatives in the Legislation Yuan. We should not wait for the national referendum to bother all of us.
If the legislators from Kuomintang insist to have the referendum for the fourth nuclear power plant, they should fulfill the following two requirements before they vote for the referendum. Otherwise, this referendum will only become a trick to fool the citizens to endorse the construction of the fourth nuclear power plant:
First, they should accomplish the report of current construction quality of the fourth nuclear power plant and confirm that it is worth our tax money so that we can consider continuing the construction.
Second, they should amend the Referendum Act. The threshold stated in this Act should be lowered to reflect citizens’ opinions faithfully.
We ask the legislators to fulfill these requirements before they vote. They should not vote for the referendum now without sufficient preparation.
We also ask the legislators who support the no-nuke activities to avoid the referendum going through the voting process.

Several organizations have prepared for the worse case scenario that the referendum be passed in the Legislation Yuan, as reported [zh] by Taiwan independent media coolloud.org:

綠盟秘書長崔愫欣[…]強調反核的民眾已經準備好面對公投,將會透過組織化動員,正面迎戰。

Secretary General of Green Citizens Action Alliance Tsui Hsiu-Hsin […] emphasized that the protesters are ready for the referendum. They will fight the government face-to-face through organizational mobilization.
The placard said: "If you don't vote for the referendum, you vote for nuclear disaster." via Facebook 洪雅書房. Public photo.

The placard said: “If you don't vote for the referendum, you vote for nuclear disaster.” via Facebook 洪雅書房. Public photo.

Now that the Legislative Yuan has agreed to suspend voting on the referendum proposal, the anti-nuclear activists will continue to pressure the government to stop the fourth nuclear power plant from operating with its administrative power.

  • Pingback: Referendum on Taiwan’s Fourth Nuclear Plant Suspended | OccuWorld

  • Pingback: Taiwanese Government Alters Search Results to Favor Nuclear Energy Policy - Global Voices Advocacy

  • Pingback: Taiwan’s Nuclear Nightmare | SimplyInfo

  • Pingback: Netizen Report: From Mauritania to Mexico, Thuggery Looms Large - Global Voices Advocacy

  • Taiwanese Guy

    I’m 100% Pro-ROTaiwan TAIWANESE, and I 100% supported on NUCLEAR ENERGY DEVELOPMENTS in My TAIWAN NATION! This is not typical BS Goody-Two-Shoe POLITICAL CORRECTNESS but a NECESSARY EVIL for TAIWAN’s very future! In fact, I and other SMARTER TAIWANESE wanted TAIWAN to have our very own and very useful HEAVY INDUSTRIES such as:

    “Mitsubishi Heavy Industries” Wiki (Soryu-class & Oyashio-class subs)
    “Kawasaki Heavy Industries” Wiki (Soryu-class & Oyashio-class subs)
    “Sumitomo Heavy Industries” Wiki
    “Fuji Heavy Industries” Wiki

    “Hyundai Heavy Industries” Wiki
    “Daewoo Shipbuilding & Marine Engineering” Wiki (Type 214 & Type 209 subs)
    “Samsung Heavy Industries” Wiki
    “Doosan Heavy Industries & Construction” Wiki (GE & AREVA of South Korea)

    “List of the largest Shipbuilding Companies” Wiki
    “Asian shipyards: The deeper the better – CommonWealth Magazine” WEB SITE
    “Taiwan’s ship-building industry– departing from the crossroads” WEB SITE
    “The ‘de-Americanization’ of Asia” WEB SITE

    TAIWAN will need those HEAVY INDUSTRIES of our very own for CREATING MORE TAIWANESE JOBS anyway! That is so I can fulfilled my promise of My TAIWAN NATION will be working on our TAIWANESE ECONOMY and building our TAIWANESE submarine fleet of 16 to 20 (including 4 Ballistic Missile Submarines with that)!! >=)

World regions

Countries

Languages