Close

Donate today to keep Global Voices strong!

Our global community of volunteers work hard every day to bring you the world's underreported stories -- but we can't do it without your help. Support our editors, technology, and advocacy campaigns with a donation to Global Voices!

Donate now

See all those languages up there? We translate Global Voices stories to make the world's citizen media available to everyone.

Learn more about Lingua Translation  »

Pakistan: Conflicting Reports in #SaveRimsha Blasphemy Case

The blasphemy law in Pakistan has been the focus of a heated debate yet again, after a 14 year old girl was accused of burning pages of Noorani Qaida, a lesson for Quran. Rimsha Masih, was arrested on August 17, 2012, after an angry mob of over a hundred brought her to the local police station. The news was first reported by the website Christian in Pakistan, which routinely published news regarding persecution of the christian community in Pakistan. As the news broke several people used twitter to verify the news and reach out to authorities to take action [see Global Voices report]. Mainstream media coverages followed and online petitions have been filed since.

But activism aside, there have been a quite few conflicting reports about the case. The most significant one being a picture of a girl, that has become the face of the #SaveRimsha campaign.

Photo Courtesy: Sunny Gill- Citizens for Democracy – People of all ages in solidarity with Rimsha, Karachi.

The issue of her name and picture

When the news first broke several mainstream media outlets referred to her as “Rifta’ instead of “Rimsha’ the name initially reported by the website Christian in Pakistan. Popular media outlets like Dawn, Express, the Guardian and even human rights group Amnesty International referred to her as Rifta in their official press release demanding her release and the repeal of the blasphemy laws.  Meanwhile, another case, of an 11 -year old Christian boy burnt to death was also reported, while it remained unclear whether this was a hate crime based on religion, a few readers reacted to the mainstream media's  error in reporting facts:

Raza Rumi (@Razarumi): RT @junaidqaiser: @rezhasan BTW name and Samual's age is not correct in ET's report.bit.ly/OwDAjH #Pakistan (August 22, 2012)

Halima Mansoor (@Hmansoor): @razarumi @junaidqaiser @rezhasan Rimsha was reported as Rifta by many, inc ET at first. Dnt knw if its poor reporting or poor systems (August 22, 2012)

Junaid Qaiser (@JunaidQaiser): @hmansoor@razarumi@rezhasan Reporting without cross checking facts. And no proper editorial check. (August 22, 2012)

The last report using the name Rifta was perhaps the 23rd of August. It is also interesting to note that news outlets have since corrected the name to Rimsha, but there has been no acknowledgement of the factual error in reporting; a standard rule in reporting. As numerous petitions and calls for protests appeared, many of them used picture of a little girl as Rimsha's picture.

Having seen the picture of the girl being used for several campaigns in the past, I decided to do trace the picture source in order to discourage people from using the picture for Rimsha. Google Images drag and drop feature was really handy to determine the source of the image, first published in April 2006 the image is of a girl in a temporary school camp in Balakot, Kashmir, taken after the 2005 earthquake (by Maciej Dakowicz).

The image of the girl has also been used by reporters and websites without verification. The Examiner.com, Huffington Post and France 24 carried the picture, but Huffington post later removed the picture.

Sunil Dixit (@sudixitca): @raushenbush @huffpostrelig -Could you please confirm/verify that this picture is indeed of Rimsha Masih? Thanks – twitter.com/sudixitca/stat… (August 22, 2012)

Paul B. Raushenbush (@raushenbush): @sudixitca I don't know, we didn't have a foto of the girl in our coverage (August 22, 2012)

Sunil Dixit (@sudixitca): @raushenbush – Sir this where I saw this picture. huffingtonpost.com/mike-ghouse/mu… (August 23, 2012)

Naeem Shamim @naeemshamim: Even marxist poets like #Faiz remained silent when State & Mullahs were persecuting #Ahmadis ! (August 27,2012)

Maham Ali (@Mahamali05): The girl in your profile picture is not Rimsha Masih @naeemshamim (August 27, 2012)

Umer Arain (@UmerArain): Indian channel running the Rimsha/blasphemy story with picture of the earthquake victim. @cyalm speaks too.youtu.be/SGwMBcQNnP8 #FAIL (August 29,2012)

A video from protests in London, shows people carrying placards with the girl's picture:

Radio France International used the picture while interviewing author Irshad Manji over the issue

Despite the picture being used by multiple news sources, only one advocacy group – Citizens For Democracy issued a clarification and an apology to discourage the use of the image:

CFD apologises for using a misleading photo with the visual earlier posted on this blog regarding the demonstration in Karachi on Aug 25. We realise that there is a need to be more thoughtful with the visuals we use with our campaigns. Please read the note below, sent to the petition owners of the Free Rimsha campaign, from a health professional in Lahore: “The photo being used with the Rimsha Masih campaign is fake and misleading. As a member of the healthcare professionals community, I can assure you the child in the photo clearly lacks any of the characteristic facial features of Down’s Syndrome [..] It is unfortunate that this photogenic-but-normal child’s picture has also been snapped up to make press club banners and illustrate other articles without appropriate verification, almost unchanged and with the incorrect labeling still intact…”

Unless mainstream media outlets recognize the error on their part it will become increasingly difficult to limit the use of the picture. Given the risks involved in cases of blasphemy, publishing a misleading picture and identity can put many people in danger.

  • malik achakzai

    Strange case,

  • Afia

    This kind of laxness in reporting makes my blood boil. Really hope the person who first used the picture will not be asked to write for any news publication again.

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=100000536141375 Mohammad Kamran

    The above mentioned photo is fake & her age is above 18 year. This all propegenda has raised to just make the Pakistan & Islam’s name “Bad”…..The real story of Ramsha Masih can be read from the link below by a eye-witness writers.. http://daily.urdupoint.com/todayColumn.php?column_id=16465&page1=10&page=10&writer_id=222&date1=2012-09-06 All the Pakistani Christians are our Brothers &Sisters. We can solve the issue internally, No need to go even in any court or in the Media…….But Shame on the enemeis of Pakistan & Islam who r just spreading the rumours & lying to just make it a big Problem for Pakistan’s public.

  • Pingback: Looking Back at 2012 in South Asia – Part II · Global Voices

Receive great stories from around the world directly in your inbox.

Sign up to receive the best of Global Voices
* = required field
Email Frequency



No thanks, show me the site