- Global Voices - http://globalvoicesonline.org -

It's Official: Puerto Rico's First Openly Lesbian Judge Has Been Appointed to the Supreme Court

Written by Ángel Carrión · Translated by Catherine Randall On 29 June 2014 @ 17:43 pm | 1 Comment

In Breaking News, Caribbean, Citizen Media, English, Feature, Gay Rights (LGBT), Good News, Human Rights, Latin America, Law, Photos, Politics, Puerto Rico (U.S.), Spanish, Weblog, Women & Gender

Maite Oronoz durante el proceso de confirmación en el Senado de Puerto Rico. Imagen tomada de video. [1]

Maite Oronoz during the confirmation process in the Puerto Rico Senate. Screenshot from video posted by the Senate.

[All links lead to Spanish-language pages, except where indicated.]

On Monday, June 23, 2014, the Puerto Rico Senate confirmed attorney Maite Oronoz Rodríguez [2] [en] as a Supreme Court judge. The historic nomination marks the first time that an openly gay individual has been appointed to the country's highest court. Oronoz Rodríguez, who is the fifth woman to serve on the Supreme Court, expressed her gratitude and pride in a written statement [3] [en]:

I am pleased that the democratic process has resulted in my nomination. I am proud to continue to serve this country, this time from the Supreme Court. My commitment to the country and to the constitution of Puerto Rico is unwavering. Through me, the people of Puerto Rico will have an honest and fair judge, loyal to the letter of the Constitution. I thank the Governor and the Senate for the opportunity to reaffirm this commitment.

The Senate's vote to confirm Oronoz Rodríguez fell mostly along partisan lines, with 16 votes in her favor and 10 against [Oronoz was nominated by the governor of Puerto Rico, Alejandro García Padilla, from the Partido Popular Democrático--Popular Democratic Party]. Among those voting against Oronoz Rodríguez was the only female senator, of the Puerto Rican Independence Party, María de Lourdes Santiago. Santiago explained [4]that her decision was based on Oronoz Rodríguez’ involvement in a controversial case, when as the director of San Juan's Municipal Legal Division she defended the Mayor's decision to impose searches on every individual who would attend this year's San Sebastian Street Festival. The searches were deemed unconstitutional in court.

The confirmation process was not without hitches. After the vote that confirmed Oronoz Rodríguez as a Supreme Court judge, some senators requested [5]a recount of the vote. Amárilis Pagán (@AmarilisPagan [6]), feminist lawyer and LGBT advocate, expressed her frustration with the process:

If it weren't for the rampant lesbophobia in the Capital, we wouldn't be in this mess over Oronoz’ confirmation. National embarrassment. 

LGBT activist Pedro Julio Serrano praised [8]Oronoz Rodríguez’ conduct during the confirmation process: 

Maite se presentó sin miedo – con todas sus identidades a flor de piel y ante la vista del País. Su nombramiento merecía esa misma valentía. Lo tuvo, a final de cuentas, pero de manera atropellada. Hay que ir de frente, sin miedo, de cara al sol, con respeto y dignidad. Como merecemos las personas LGBTT, como merecemos tod@s l@s seres human@s.

Maite presented herself fearlessly – with all her identities in full view of the country. Her appointment [as a judge] merits this same bravery. It happened, at the end of the day, but in a tumultuous way. We must proceed straightforwardly, without fear, faces to the sun, with respect and dignity. As we LGBT individuals deserve. As all humans deserve.

The new judge was congratulated by Puerto Rican Congress members Luis Gutiérrez and Nydia Velázquez via Twitter:

In a column for digital magazine 80 grados, queer activist Yoryie Irizarry (@CyborgYoryie [12]) astutely observed that this historic moment is the fruit of the LGBT community's long fight for equality [13]:

A diferencia de lo que piensan nuestras aliadas y aliados, yo he decidido pensar que ese momento histórico no nos viene cortesía del gobernador Alejandro García Padilla. Este momento histórico nos lo hemos ganado en las calles, en las legislaturas, en nuestras comunidades y empleos, educando, haciéndonos visibles, deponiendo, escribiendo, firmando cartas, debatiendo y trabajando.

Contrary to what our allies may think, I've decided to think that this historic moment does not come to us courtesy of Governor Alejandro García Padilla. We've earned this historic moment in the streets, in the legislature, in our communities and workplaces, educating, making ourselves visible, testifying, writing, signing letters, fighting, and working.

The public discussion raised by Oronoz Rodríguez’ nomination highlights society's persistent fixation on the sexual orientation of public figures, to the point that fundamental issues, like her performance and knowledge, are taking a backseat. In an article for digital magazine El Post Antillano, Jaime Pieras Castañer describes [14]the problem:

Cuando se discutía el nombramiento en los medios se enfatizaba demasiado en la orientación social de la nominada. Aparentemente, hubiese estado bien si no fuese sincera sobre su orientación sexual, pero lo dijo. Thomas Rivera Schatz, ex presidente del Senado, expresó en un apasionado discurso [...] en el Senado que ella era la que había traído a la atención que era lesbiana. Bah, como si eso tuviese que ver con sus clasificaciones o con las consideraciones que deben de ser parte de cualquier deliberación sobre los dotes o el talento de Oronoz.

The media coverage of the nomination focused too much on the social orientation of the nominee. Apparently, it would have been fine if she weren't open about her sexual orientation, but she disclosed it. Thomas Rivera Schatz, ex-president of the Senate, said in a heated speech [...] in the Senate that [Oronoz Rodríguez] herself brought her sexual orientation to public attention. As if that has anything to do with her qualifications or with any of the factors that should be part of any discussion of Oronoz’ gifts and talent.

Érika Fontánez Torres, lawyer, Law professor and editor of the digital magazine Derecho al Derecho, offers an interesting opinion in the magazine's podcast [15](at around minute 11:20):

Hay alguna gente que a raíz de toda esta discusión ha dicho “no, es que no es importante, no es relevante que ella sea lesbiana o no” y, bueno, lo primero que tendríamos que decir, “sí, que sí que lo es”, […] sí que las subjetividades son importantes en el Tribunal, sí que añaden a la mesa, sí que la diversidad es importante a la hora de la deliberación de los jueces […], y si esa persona tiene, como en el caso de Maite Oronoz, una experiencia de vida desde esa ubicación, eso me parece extraordinario.

There are some people who have responded to this discussion by saying, “No, it's not important, it's irrelevant whether or not she's a lesbian,” but well, the first thing we should be saying is “Yes, yes, it is important”… yes, subjectivities are important in Court, yes, they do bring something to the table, yes, diversity is important when the judges are deliberating [...], and if an individual, like Maite Oronoz, has a life experience from that perspective, I would say that's extraordinary.


Article printed from Global Voices: http://globalvoicesonline.org

URL to article: http://globalvoicesonline.org/2014/06/29/its-official-puerto-ricos-first-openly-lesbian-judge-has-been-appointed-to-the-supreme-court/

URLs in this post:

[1] Image: http://youtu.be/hixdoOaAoig

[2] Maite Oronoz Rodríguez: http://globalvoicesonline.org/2014/06/05/first-openly-gay-person-nominated-for-puerto-ricos-supreme-court/

[3] written statement: http://www.sanjuanweeklypr.com/pdf/ediciones-pasadas/June-25-14.pdf

[4] explained : http://www.metro.pr/locales/senadora-decepcionada-con-maite-oronoz/pGXnft!FHslTAUsa9go/

[5] requested : http://www.elnuevodia.com/doblementeconfirmadaenelsenadolajuezamaiteoronozrodriguez-1799626.html

[6] @AmarilisPagan: https://twitter.com/AmarilisPagan

[7] June 23, 2014: https://twitter.com/AmarilisPagan/statuses/481178076991062017

[8] praised : http://http//pedrojulioserrano.com/2014/06/23/celebra-confirmacion-de-lesbiana-al-tribunal-supremo/

[9] #LGBT: https://twitter.com/hashtag/LGBT?src=hash

[10] June 23, 2014: https://twitter.com/RepGutierrez/statuses/481124829115207680

[11] June 16, 2014: https://twitter.com/NydiaVelazquez/statuses/478540968921415681

[12] @CyborgYoryie: https://twitter.com/CyborgYoryie

[13] long fight for equality: http://www.80grados.net/nominacion-suprema-para-la-comunidad-lgbt/

[14] describes : http://elpostantillano.com/justicia-social/10691-jaime-pieras-castaner.html

[15] podcast : http://derechoalderecho.org/2014/06/12/episodio-17-podcast-pensando-el-derecho-nominacion-al-supremo/

Licensed Creative Commons Attribution, 2008 Global Voices Online. See attribution policy for details: http://globalvoicesonline.org/about/global-voices-attribution-policy