- Global Voices - http://globalvoicesonline.org -
How Technology and Citizen Media Shaped Taiwan's Sunflower Movement
Written by I-fan Lin On 20 April 2014 @ 1:58 am | 4 Comments
In Citizen Media, Digital Activism, East Asia, English, Feature, Protest, Taiwan (ROC), Technology, Weblog
Throughout the three-week occupation of Taiwan's legislative building  by protesters angry over a secretly negotiated trade deal with China, citizen media played an important role in keeping the public informed.
Members of the Sunflower Movement set up a number of websites dedicated to the protest and the Cross-Strait Service and Trade Agreement (CSSTA), whose passage by the legislature in mid-March without a clause-by-clause review sparked the occupation. Some worried the trade agreement would make democratic Taiwan vulnerable to political pressure from the communist mainland.
Thousands of people turned up and protested outside the Legislative Yuan alongside those inside. Half a million citizens also took to the streets to support the protest  on March 30.
Protesters left the Legislative Yuan, as the country's legislature is known, on April 10 after the speaker promised to pass legislation monitoring future agreements proposed by the executive branch before deliberating on the current deal.
Live-streams were available for those who wished to follow along with the occupation. Tang Fong, a tech activist, explained  on website 0th Sunflower Digital Camp how they created an online hub to collect all live-streams of the protests and improved the live broadcast  system inside the occupied legislature to safeguard the protesters from police violence:
On March 23, at the MoeDict Hackthon, we repurposed the domain name we registered a while ago, g0v.today, to collect all the direct streams for everyone, including the English translation task force .
On March 28, a team from ITRI showed up, saying “there are still blind spots, like in some corridors in the Academia Sinica” [a code name for the legislative building], and helped set up six more cameras and capture videos from the blind spots. NO incident NOR brutal events ever happened after the cameras were up. We appreciated what they’ve done and hence shared much bandwidth.
If it is even 1% due to what we did that few people were injured, and no one went missing, then I think it is worth it.
Police aggression was indeed a reality that protesters faced. On March 23, demonstrators attempted to occupy the Executive Yuan, but were suppressed by riot police with rods and water cannons. Several protesters, doctors and journalists were injured.
As the Taiwanese government did not inform the public about the details of the CSSTA, a number of citizen-initiated websites were created to explain the agreement and its potential impact. Tech blog Cool3c.com  highlighted some of the initiatives:
服貿跑馬燈 將所有服貿相關新聞直接一行一行排下來，雖然界面上沒那麼好看，但新聞的旁邊還增添了 Facebook 上貼文者的註解，反而更有由下而上的素人評論新聞效果。
CSSTA news ticker  [zh] lists CSSTA-related news one by one. Although its interface is not very pretty, the comments besides the news taken from Facebook make it feel close to the common people.
(自己的服貿自己審)  將服貿全文、公聽會逐字稿、產業評估報告全部整合和立法院專案報告全都整理起來。可快速查詢服務貿易協定和你公司的相關性。
(Let us review the CSSTA for ourselves)  [zh] summarizes the full text of the CSSTA, transcripts of previous public hearings, evaluations of affected industries, and project reports from the Legislative Yuan. Now it is easy to check out how the CSSTA might affect your company.
國會無雙  […] 這個網站試題以「播報體育賽事」的方式來代替原本無趣的立法院實況，並在公聽會安排「主播」和「球評」，讓對政治冷感的一般公民可以用非常具娛樂性的方式來親近政治議題，是邁向「政治普及」的重要里程碑。
Our one and the only one congress  [zh] […] tries to make the experience of watching real-time broadcasts from the Legislative Yuan similar to the experience of watching sports. They have anchors and critics for the real-time broadcast of public hearings so everyday people who usually don't care about politics can learn about these political issues in an entertaining way. This is an important milestone for “popularized politics”.
To monitor the government and legislature and make sure they fulfilled their promise of setting up a monitoring mechanism for future cross-strait agreements, the tech activist Tang Fong set up a new platform together with her friends:
On March 27, we set up another website, 123.g0v.today, where you can find the phone number of the legislator for your election area. You might call and demand for the legislation [for a cross-strait agreement-monitoring mechanism] before review of the pact proceeds, and invite the legislator to join the camp.
Their g0v server also hosts a calendar for the Legislative Yuan  so that citizens can easily know what is going on there.
The emergence of this website allows citizens to understand their right to recall (which is usually not of concern for most of us).
This website has become a key platform for protesters to keep tabs on lawmakers after the end of the occupation.
The Facebook page of National Taiwan University's E-Forum attracted more than 100,000 followers during the Sunflower Movement because their student reporters covered the protest 24 hours a day from inside and outside the legislature. They explained  [zh] how their citizen reporting evolved throughout the protests:
On March 20, about ten student reporters brought their cell phones, notebooks, rental cameras, video cameras and 4G mobile base station to Jinan Road and started their interviews. In the beginning, they worked on the roadside, and later they moved to a tent on Jinan Road. At the end, they had a semi-formal newsroom. In the beginning, there were only few students from the Graduate Institute of Journalism of National Taiwan University. At the end, it became a huge workforce composed of around 90 students from National Chengchi University, National Taiwan Normal University and National Dong Hwa University supporting the coverage of the protest in several locations.
Technology also helped to facilitate logistics for the protests. cool3c  highlighed some of the tools:
A masterpiece (initiated by ETBlue and supported by several others) by making use of maps engine to generate a map for #CongressOccupied  [zh]. This map marked the podiums, toilets, and convenience stores clearly.
(立院排班表) : 使用者可透過 Facebook 的帳號登入，立即瞭解自己的朋友在立法院排班的狀態，自己也可以加入排班，讓朋友間互相提醒。
(Calendar for taking shifts at the Legislative Yuan)  [zh]: Users could log in with their Facebook accounts. They could see their friends’ shifts in the Legislative Yuan, and they could sign up and take their shift [as a voluntary security guard]. Friends could use this website to remind each other of their shifts.
flyingV , a crowdfunding platform, was initially set up to raise funds for newspaper advertisement for the movement. On April 7, VDemocracy.tw  was created as an additional fundraising website specifically for social activists. Another Internet fundraising project was hosted by zeczec.com  to publish a photobook for the Sunflower Movement.
Betty Eric explained  how protesters organized themselves despite their differences:
In this student movement, the protocol is defined by their determination and their tools. We can see that they used to belong to different independent groups that have different goals and demands. Nevertheless, they have the same protocol: against the “black box” secretive process behind the CSSTA. As a result, after some minor adjustments, these groups can be easily connected to each other.
While there is major divergence in their opinions, what they likely do is separating their network. Therefore, they can keep their own opinions instead of changing their original goals. […] This kind of Internet democracy does not compromise easily. As a result, the conflict between the government and the protesters might be elongated.
Article printed from Global Voices: http://globalvoicesonline.org
URL to article: http://globalvoicesonline.org/2014/04/20/how-technology-and-citizen-media-shaped-taiwans-sunflower-movement/
URLs in this post:
 Image: https://www.facebook.com/photo.php?fbid=10152131402308423&set=pcb.10152131405028423&type=1&theater
 occupation of Taiwan's legislative building: http://globalvoicesonline.org/2014/03/19/protesters-occupy-taiwans-legislature-over-china-trade-deal/
 support the protest: http://globalvoicesonline.org/2014/03/31/half-a-milion-taiwanese-assemble-to-support-congressoccupied/
 explained: https://0sdc.tw/en
 live broadcast: https://www.facebook.com/notes/%E5%94%90%E9%B3%B3/first-year-of-g0v-march-2014-transcript/808828052479750
 English translation task force: http://globalvoicesonline.org/2014/03/21/taiwans-congressoccupied-protest-translated/
 Cool3c.com: http://www.cool3c.com/article/78266
 服貿跑馬燈: http://ecfa.speaking.tw/
 (自己的服貿自己審): http://review.fumao.today/
 國會無雙: http://musou.tw/
 a calendar for the Legislative Yuan: http://ly.g0v.tw/calendar/today
 Appendectomy Project: http://appy.tw/
 cool3c.com: http://globalvoicesonline.orgcool3c http://www.cool3c.com/article/78266
 explained: https://www.facebook.com/NtuNewsEForum/photos/a.525692650793292.102822322.155846434444584/817950284900859/?type=1&stream_ref=10
 Image: http://instagram.com/p/mX6TQKFEC3/
 「佔領立法院地圖」: https://mapsengine.google.com/map/viewer?mid=zlxW8eSZKLlk.k1Nzj2E6NfgY
 (立院排班表): http://antifumao.meteor.com/
 flyingV: http://www.flyingv.cc/
 VDemocracy.tw: http://globalvoicesonline.orgVDemocracy.tw
 zeczec.com: http://www.zeczec.com/projects/sunflowerphoto
 explained: http://blog.xuite.net/betty.eric/scandinavia/209265981
Licensed Creative Commons Attribution, 2008 Global Voices Online. See attribution policy for details: http://globalvoicesonline.org/about/global-voices-attribution-policy