See all those languages up there? We translate Global Voices stories to make the world's citizen media available to everyone.

Learn more about Lingua Translation  »

Crash that Killed Cuban Democracy Advocate Still Shrouded in Mystery

The car accident that killed democracy advocate Oswaldo Payá has been shrouded in mystery and misinformation since it happened in eastern Cuba last July.

Payá, who dedicated his life to promoting human rights and democratic governance in Cuba, died along with his colleague, advocate Harold Cepero. Angel Carromero and Jens Aron Modig, European politicians who were visiting Cuba to support Payá's efforts, survived the crash.

Oswaldo Paya, at his home. Screenshot from video by Tracey Eaton, taken with photographer's permission.

Oswaldo Paya, at his home. Screenshot from video by Tracey Eaton, taken with photographer's permission.

While state press and Cuban officials [es] reported that Carromero, who was at the wheel, lost control of the car and hit a tree, rumors of a second car began to circulate. Though the two Europeans survived the crash, weeks passed before either survivor gave an account of the accident. Having endured decades of harassment and threats on her father’s life, Payá’s daughter Rosa Maria publicly stated that she suspected foul play. Cuban authorities charged Carromero with vehicular manslaughter; he was put on trial in October, found guilty, and sentenced to four years in prison. Carromero also delivered a statement, before the press, confirming authorities’ version of the story.

Given that the passengers killed in the accident were in the back seat of the car, the claim that the car crashed into a tree seems unlikely.

This month, Angel Carromero, who served jail time in Cuba and was then (with assistance from the Spanish government) granted permission to complete his sentence in Spain, gave an interview to The Washington Post. The newspaper’s website does not specify who conducted the interview.

In this new account of the accident and its aftermath, Carromero describes being followed by a series of strange cars, the last of which crashed into the back of the car, killing Payá and Cepero, who were riding in the backseat. Carromero recalls being taken to a hospital and later asked to sign the “official” account of the accident and recite the account before members of the press.

Carromero says that military officers intimidated him, suggesting that he would face further trouble if he did not stick to the official version of the story.

One of them told me that what I had told them had not happened and that I should be careful, that depending on what I said things could go very well or very badly for me.

He also describes meager prison conditions and claims that while he was in the hospital, personnel unnecessarily sedated him. He believes this may have caused his memory of the incident to lapse.

Phil Peters, US-Cuba policy expert and author of The Cuban Triangle, is doubtful that those following the case will find Carromero’s account credible:

…[Carromero’s] conduct to date has frustrated those that most want to pin Paya’s death on the Cuban government, and the presentation of the case – slow, late, and piecemeal, with Modig consistently useless – has limited its impact.  My strong guess is that skeptics of both accounts are not going to get satisfaction.

Carromero claims that when they saw a vehicle following them, Paya and Cepero said it was “from ‘la comunista.’”  Peters notes that this doesn't sound right — Cubans do not colloquially refer to authorities this way. “La comunista” would be a pretty general way to refer to just about anyone in Cuba, a Communist country.

Spanish Foreign Minister José Manuel García-Margallo says he has no reason to believe Carromero. Spanish daily El Pais notes that the Spanish government has handled the case delicately, likely in the interest of preserving Cuba-Spain relations and protecting other Spanish citizens who are awaiting trial in Cuba.

Havana Times reports that García-Margallo has said that Carromero should present this information before the court. At his trial, Carromero gave what he now claims was a false description of the accident.

Havana Times blogger Harold Dilla also expressed skepticism about Carromero’s account. He noted that people on all sides of the incident seem to have given accounts and spread information that is not entirely truthful– the lack of impartial, thorough reporting on the incident has made the situation all the worse. Dilla wrote,

The unfortunate death of Oswaldo Paya is another example of the morbidities that come with the lack of information openness in Cuba and the lack of independent response channels.

Although the Cuban government acted to provide rapid and technically supported information on the facts of the incident, I don’t think it was sufficient for anyone, if we consider that Paya was always considered an enemy and harassed accordingly.

Dilla also supported the Paya family’s request for an independent investigation of the case and argued that “the Cuban government should, in the name of decency, be obligated to allow that.”

Many have called for an independent investigation of the accident; the Payá family has sought assistance on the matter from the United Nations. But even this may be a challenge. Agustín López casts doubt [es] on the efficacy of such an effort

¿Qué tribunal internacional tendrá la suficiente potestad para realizar una investigación imparcial y por qué métodos obtendrán pruebas periciales que no sean fraudulentas? ¿Se dignara algún cubano que conozca la verdad a arriesgar la vida en una transparente declaración?

What international court will have sufficient power to conduct an impartial investigation and what methods will be used to obtain credible evidence that will not be fraudulent? Will any Cuban who knows the truth to deign to risk his or her life by making a transparent statement?

In the wake of the accident, a diverse range of Cuban voices — even those who didn’t agree with Payá — expressed appreciation for his efforts to push for reform on the island. Payá was internationally recognized as one of Cuba's most pragmatic, forward-thinking advocates for freedom of expression, freedom of association, and other fundamental rights on the island. For Payá's family and those who supported his work, it is unfortunate that his death has been marked on all sides by layers of misinformation and mistrust.

2 comments

  • Humberto Capiro

    SOME INTERESTING THINGS ABOUT THE OFFICIAL OSWALDO PAYA “ACCIDENT” VIDEO
    (link below) RELEASED BY THE CASTRO “GOVERNMENT” ! THEY ARE THE FOLLOWING AND
    YOU CAN LOOK AT THEM YOURSELVES!!

    THE DEFORMED FRONT BUMPER THAT DISAPPEARED & THE REAR BUMPER WITH
    DENT!
    1. At the beginning of the video the car is shown with the front bumper
    all mangled and twisted out on both sides but at 5:00 minutes the front twisted
    bumper has disappeared. It is obvious that the car has been tampered with due to
    the fact that it lost its bumper! Was it moved there and the bumper was torn off
    due to the hauling? Also, if you stop the video @ 5:03 there is a shot of the
    rear bumper showing a dent in the right hand side. How could this have happened
    if the car crashed against the tree on the opposite side? Looks like another car
    hit it from the rear! You can see manipulated photo of the rear bumper showing a
    very shiny and inconsistent texture on the right side @ 0.22 seconds into the
    video unlike that @ 5:03 minutes.

    WHY NO PHOTOS OF Oswaldo Pay & Harold Cepero
    2. Interesting that at
    the beginning of the video the four passengers are identified with their
    location but while showing pictures of Angel Carromero & Jens Aron Morig
    there are no pictures to identify Oswaldo Pay & Harold Cepero!! Fear of the
    Cuban people and others to identify with them as victims and to keep their faces
    out of the eyes of the Cuban people!

    THE OBVIOUS COACHING OF THE SPANISH AND SWEDISH WITNESSES
    3. If you pay
    attention to the eye movement of both the Spanish Angel Carromero and the Swede
    Jens Aron Modig you can see how off screen they are reading something to help
    them in their statements. They are very poor actors and it is very obvious they
    are being coached. In addition both of their body languages tell how
    uncomfortable they are doing this.

    YOUTUBE: CUBADEBATE: Oswaldo Payá Sardiñas: Testimonios sobre el
    accidente- Oswaldo Payá Sardiñas: Testimonies about the accident.
    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EBOphUw5RM8

    TOO MANY INCONSISTENCIES ABOUT THIS VIDEO EVIDENCE DONT YOU THINK SO? WORTH
    A LOOK BY AN INDEPENDENT INTERNATIONAL TEAM OF EXPERTS!

  • Humberto Capiro

    THE LATE CUBAN DISSIDENT AND LEADER OF THE “LADIES IN WHITE” WAS
    ALSO A VICTIM OF AN “ACCIDENT” WHEN THE CAR SHE WAS TRAVELING WITH ITALIAN FILM
    MAKER Pierantonio Maria Micciarelli WAS HIT FROM BEHIND AND ALMOST WENT OFF THE
    ROAD! CHECK OUT THE VIDEO BELOW OF THAT MOMENT! BOTH LAURA POLLAN & OSWALDO
    PAYA, BOTH WINNERS OF THE Sakharov Prize HAVE DIED IN THE PAST YEAR UNDER
    MYSTERIOUS CIRCUMSTANCES! COINCIDENCE??

    VIDEO: The car where the late Cuban dissident Laura Pollan (her
    death of “dengue” was never fully explained) is traveling gets hit from
    behind in the documentary “Soy la otra Cuba” (I am the other Cuba) and almost
    caused a horrific accident @ 4:30 minutes into segment! THIS IS NO COINCIDENCE
    OR “ACCIDENT”!

    http://vimeo.com/31316770#at=0

Join the conversation

Authors, please log in »

Guidelines

  • All comments are reviewed by a moderator. Do not submit your comment more than once or it may be identified as spam.
  • Please treat others with respect. Comments containing hate speech, obscenity, and personal attacks will not be approved.

Receive great stories from around the world directly in your inbox.

No thanks, show me the site