Close

Donate today to keep Global Voices strong!

Watch the video: We Are Global Voices!

We report on 167 countries. We translate in 35 languages. We are Global Voices. Watch the video »

Over 800 of us from all over the world work together to bring you stories that are hard to find by yourself. But we can’t do it alone. Even though most of us are volunteers, we still need your help to support our editors, our technology, outreach and advocacy projects, and our community events.

Donate now »
GlobalVoices in Learn more »

Outrage Brews in China Over Hong Kong Milk Powder Regulation

On the first day of a new restriction that limits travelers from taking more than 1.8 kg of infant milk formula out of Hong Kong, border authorities arrested 10 people in violation of the new law. The new regulations were implemented on March 1, 2013. A 47-year-old man was prosecuted March 2, and fined 5000 HKD [zh] (approximately 650 USD). The maximum penalty for smuggling milk powder out of Hong Kong would be a 500,000 HKD fine and 2-year imprisonment.

Mainland Chinese media outlets are divided in their opinion on the policy. Commentators in the newspaper Global Times criticize [zh] the policy as a de facto embargo that violates the principle of free trade. On the other hand, CCTV and the China Daily point out in their micro-blog comments [zh] that the mainland Chinese milk industry is to be blamed for the current situation.

As most of the mainland Chinese do not understand that the policy is targeting smugglers rather than normal visitors, many are outraged, in particular by the 2-year imprisonment penalty. Famous mainland Chinese property developer Pan Shiyi [zh] describes the policy as a modern version of Les Miserables:

刚看完电影《悲惨世界》,电影不错。法国大革命前夕,冉阿让给妹妹的孩子偷了一块面包,被判了五年刑。今天,2013年为给三岁以下孩子多买二罐奶粉,要判二年徒刑。@香港立法会所有成员 。

Just watched the movie Les Miserables. It is a great movie. Before the French revolution, Jean Valjean stole a piece of bread for his sister and was sentenced to 5 years in prison. Today, in 2013, people are sentenced to 2 years in prison for buying more than 2 cans of milk powder for their 3-year-old infant. @Hong Kong Legislative Council Members.

Former CEO of Google China Lee Kai-fu points out [zh] that both the Chinese government and Hong Kong government should be blamed for the ridiculous situation:

香港奶粉事件的谬论和回应:1)“应批评内地而非香港”:批评为何要二选一?毒奶粉、过高关税、荒谬徒刑我们都应批评,2)”挑拨香港内地人感情“ :批评的是法律不是人,请勿乱扣帽子,3)”香港人买不到奶粉,所以法律合理“:请勿偷换概念:保护、限制两罐,甚至罚款都可以理解,离谱的是两年徒刑!

Comment on the fallacies concerning the Hong Kong milk powder incident: 1. Fallacy: We should criticize mainland China rather than Hong Kong – Why do we have to choose between the two? We should criticize the poisonous milk, the expensive taxation on foreign milk and the ridiculous penalty. 2. Fallacy: The criticism will create antagonism between Hong Kong and mainland Chinese – We are criticizing the law, not Hong Kong people. Do not label the discussion. 3. Fallacy: As Hong Kong people are facing milk powder shortage, the regulation is thus justified – Don't mix up the concepts: We can understand protection, restriction and fine, but a 2-year prison term is outrageous!

Ah Qiang, the director of PFLAG China, curses Hong Kong [zh]:

如果在港买3罐奶粉不但要罚50万,还要判监两年,我只能说:香港,我草你妈的法治和自由!这跟带把水果刀被牢教两年有毛的区别!我们要批评毒奶粉和内地当局的不作为,不代表就要原谅香港政府对法制的亵渎。当民粹替代法治,香港精神只剩意淫。

If buying three cans of milk powder results in a 500,000 HKD fine and 2 years in prison, my reaction is: Hong Kong, fuck your rule of law and freedom! It is like a 2-year forced labour education sentence when [the Chinese police] find people holding a small knife. Of course we have to criticize the mainland Chinese government for its inability [to maintain food security], and the poisonous milk scandal. However, we cannot forgive the Hong Kong government's abuse of the law. It is replacing rule of law with populist sentiment and the eventual erosion of Hong Kong spirit.

As more and more countries have imposed restriction on the export of infant milk powder, Chinese parents are desperate to find safe milk for their children. Children's book writer Zhen Yuanji also laments [zh]:

卖坏奶粉的不坐牢买好奶粉的坐牢童话都不敢这么写儿童安全是国家的头等大事。值此政府换届两会召开政府机构改革之际,呼吁组建国务院奶粉部,由副总理兼任奶粉部长。奶粉直接关系到国家的未来。

Those who sell the poisonous milk stay out of jail. Those who try to buy good milk powder are put into prison. The reality is crazier than fiction. Children's security should be prioritized in national policy. I urge that in the process of government transition, the state council should set up a milk powder office headed by the deputy premier to handle the situation. Milk powder security will affect the future of the country.

Micro-blogger Silly Child reminds [zh] those who are unhappy about the Hong Kong policy about the story of Zhao Lianhai, an activist in the 2008 Chinese milk scandal who was sentenced to 2.5 in prison for his part in the backlash against the government.

Zhao Lianhai was sentenced to 2.5 years in prison for "disturbing social order." Photo from Boxun.

Zhao Lianhai was sentenced to 2.5 years in prison for “disturbing social order.” Photo from Boxun. Non-commercial use.

As Zhao's name is still unsearchable in Chinese social media, the micro-blogger uploaded his post in image format:

Silly Child's post in image format.

Silly Child's post in image format.

We only have one Zhao Lianhai, that's why he is in jail. If we have 10 Zhaos, they will censor your voices; if we have 100 Zhaos, they can't do anything; if we have 1000 Zhaos, they will be frightened; if we have 10,000 Zhaos, the Chinese milk problem can be solved. China only has one Zhao Lianhai, though we have 10,000 people cursing the Hong Kong milk powder policy.

Indeed, while anger abounds, signs of any strong public movement are absent in the outrage.

World regions

Countries

Languages