Close

Donate today to keep Global Voices strong!

Watch the video: We Are Global Voices!

We report on 167 countries. We translate in 35 languages. We are Global Voices. Watch the video »

Over 800 of us from all over the world work together to bring you stories that are hard to find by yourself. But we can’t do it alone. Even though most of us are volunteers, we still need your help to support our editors, our technology, outreach and advocacy projects, and our community events.

Donate now »
GlobalVoices in Learn more »

One Joke Too Many? Bhutanomics Satire Blog is Suddenly Blocked

Rousing suspicions that Bhutan's government does not appreciate the humor of political satire blog Bhutanomics, the website was blocked on January 12, 2013 from a major internet service provider with no explanation or warning.

In less than one year of existence since launching in March 2012, the group blog has created ripples in Bhutan's political sphere with a series of satirical report cards for politicians and government officials, and as a popular open platform for anonymous government criticism and political analysis.

Bhutanomics has also been criticized for slander and lack of editorial oversight. According to its about page, it's a non-partisan website sustained only via donations.

On January 12, the following was reported through the blog's Facebook page:

Some very powerful people in Bhutan dont like us. Our website (http://bhutanomics.com/) is no longer accessible from Bhutan.

From Bhutanomic's Facebook Page

From Bhutanomic's Facebook Page

Minjur Dorji reports at The Bhutanese:

Bhutanomics.com, a satirical website has been blocked by Druknet, one of the Internet Service Providers (ISPs) in the country. This was confirmed by a Druknet employee though he and his colleagues did not share who gave the instructions to do so.

Nobody is really sure whether the website is operated within the country or the webmaster resides outside Bhutan.

Suspicions of censorship are heightened because Bhutanomics is only inaccessible on Druknet, the main ISP operated by state-owned Bhutan Telecom. It is still accessible through private ISPs like Tashi Cell and Samden. The site is also accessible through proxy websites, via social media and by users abroad.

Screen shot of Bhutanomics.com

Screen shot of Bhutanomics.com on February 5, 2013

According to news reports, both the Druknet General Manager, Tshering Norbu, and Media Officer of Bhutan InfoComm and Media Authority, Lakshuman Chhetri, have denied blocking the site.

Rinzin comments on the above mentioned article:

The blocking of Bhutannomics will push Bhutan into an elite club of countries like North Korea, China, Iran and Syria where the internet is actively controlled by the government to block critical websites.

The Bhutanomics blog posts an open letter to the Bhutanese Prime Minister that was originally posted by Jamyang Y. S. as a comment on the site.

If a government cannot uphold itself to the criticism by its subjects, then how will the government function? I believe it is the criticism that can be used as a check and balance to see how your party is doing, and the true health of your governing system. I believe that when you take on to become a politician, it is only natural that there will be criticism – both critical and cynical, but it is up to you how you hold on to it.

Blogger Peldhen Sonam Nima wonders whether the ban will do any good for the country:

Bhutanomics entertained me. Its been a source of so many interesting happenings. I liked the satire part which has link especially to Bhutanese Political setting. [..]

I think it has updates on all the famous Bhutanese personalities. Its understandable why my fellas in Bhutan will miss the Banned blog. [..]

They are all people who have the potential to either make or break Bhutan! I think any Bhutanese deserve to know both plus points and minus points of those individuals.

Monu GhishYing Tamang opines that:

Bhutan is a young democracy which requires adequate criticism to grow strong. Criticism should not be taken in a wrong way, it must be the correction fluid to erase our follies.

However the blogger also thinks that a number of writers and contributors of Bhutanomics need to reveal their identity for the sake of credibility.

  • deki

    We are no longer eager to read Bhutanomics as it criticises only one side of the party. You have caused total destruction to the nation building with all false reports. Whoever are involved in these matter may encounter an untimely suffering and finally die of guilt.

  • Pingback: Limits on Net Freedoms Across South Asia « South Asia Jurist

  • TASHI

    people should not bind themselves to one idea. Those who don’t like bhutanomics are those people who don’t like change. They wanted to stick to those old tradition of corruptions. From my view, constructive criticism can guide you from bad practices. It gives you information on how to change your performances. Its a mirror that reflects you so if you think you are degenerating, you can also see on how to improve yourself. As said ‘Criticism may not be agreeable, but it is necessary. It fulfils the same function as pain in the human body. It calls attention to an unhealthy state of things’.

    Winston Churchill

World regions

Countries

Languages