- Global Voices - http://globalvoicesonline.org -
China Considers Real Name Registration for All Internet Users
Written by Abby On 26 December 2012 @ 3:21 am | 1 Comment
In China, Citizen Media, East Asia, English, Feature, Freedom of Speech, Law, Technology, Weblog
Following the call for more internet supervision  by state-run People’s Daily newspaper last week, Xinhua news reported  on December 24, 2012 that the Chinese government is considering a new law requiring real-name registration for its 500 million internet users.
According to Xinhua, the legislation would “safeguard” Internet users from defamation and fraud. Li Fei, deputy director of the Commission for Legislative Affairs of the NPC Standing Committee, said:
Such identity management could be conducted backstage, allowing users to use different names when publicizing information.
Although Chinese microblogging service Sina Weibo was required to introduce real-name registration earlier this year, implementation has been bogged down  because of technical difficulties. Now the government is taking it to legislation, which could have a major impact on China’s social networking services such as Weibo which supports over 400 million registered users. While some netizens think it’s necessary to regulate the fast growing Internet service in China to protect personal information and avoid fraud, many worry that the move is just another way to further restrict freedom of speech.
Liao Rui, a lawyer based in China's Sichuan province said  on Weibo:
是近来微博等网络媒体上络绎不绝的反腐败举报。 恳请全国人大常委，在审议此议案时， 如有涉及限制宪法规定的公民言论自由权利的违宪条款时， 能严肃对待，以对国家、民族负责任的态度，投下你自己一票！
廖睿 ：The direct motivation of the proposal is the constant stream of anti-corruption comments on social media recently. I urge the Standing Committee of the National People's Congress to treat this proposal seriously as it involves citizens’ freedom of speech which the Constitution has regulated. Cast your own vote with responsibility to country and the nation!
Another lawyer and writer wrote  on Weibo:
法客瑾爷 ：The law is of great significance, helping to protect the reputation of Internet users and prevent cyber crime. But there is no guarantee that it will not become an accomplice to the government in interfering with freedom of speech.
Lawyer Liu Xiaoyuan with 70,000 followers on Weibo cited South Korea’s failed attempt for real-name registration as example:
络实名制违背了宪法。 宪法法院称互联网实名制阻碍了用户自由表达意见， 没有身份证号的外国人很难登录留言板， 此外留言板信息外泄的可能性增大，从这些因素来看， 这一制度的不利影响并不小于其公益性。
刘晓原律师 : On August 23, 2012, South Korea's Constitutional Court made the decision. Eight judges found that real-name registration violates the Constitution, as the Constitutional Court said that the Internet real-name system would hinder users’ freedom of expression, foreigners without ID numbers would have difficulty logging onto message boards, in addition, it also increases leaking of message board information. Judging by these factors, disadvantages far surpass any advantages that could have come from real-name registration.
What do ordinary netizens think?
东来和西去 ：I don’t know the intention of this law, is it to protect our freedom of speech or to control it?
扬尘无导 ：Real-name registration is not scary, but being punished for online speech is.
实际也没啥。本来真要找你也是分分钟的事，现在就少走一个程序。 短期会让人恐惧，长期会给人勇气，让人有担当。掘墓的， 焉知不是为自家准备。
zhang3 : The big Christmas gift prepared for so many days is Internet real-name registration. In fact it’s no big deal. It’s already easy for them to find you anyway, now it’s even easier. In the short term, it’s terrifying. In the long run, it makes us more brave. Who knows, the ones who dig the grave are not expecting to lay in it themselves.
游离的世界已经灰白 ：The Internet is a sword hanging over the head of officials! Legislation is necessary, but the key is how to deal with both the protection of officials and the protection of citizens’ freedom of speech. Which comes the first?
Zhan Jiang, a professor at Beijing International Studies University suggested :
并扩大政府信息公开范围；同时对言论自由制定保护性法律， 然后才能进行限制性立法。否则，网络实名制最后可能法不责众， 不了了之。
First we should elevate Government Information Publicity Regulations to law, and expand the scope of public disclosure of government information; at the same time, introducing laws protective of freedom of expression before developing restrictive legislation. Otherwise, real-name registration may not work out due to public criticism.
It is still unclear if or when the law would be implemented. In the past few weeks, the government has also obstructed pathways normally used by foreign VPN services for dodging censorship restrictions. It looks bleak for anyone hoping for looser Internet control in China.
Article printed from Global Voices: http://globalvoicesonline.org
URL to article: http://globalvoicesonline.org/2012/12/26/china-considers-real-name-registration-for-all-internet-users/
URLs in this post:
 call for more internet supervision: http://globalvoicesonline.org/2012/12/21/china-cautioned-the-internet-is-not-outside-the-law/
 reported: http://news.xinhuanet.com/english/china/2012-12/24/c_132059941.htm
 bogged down: http://globalvoicesonline.orgttp://asia.cnet.com/blogs/real-name-registration-in-china-a-bad-joke-that-turned-into-a-farce-62213948.htm
 Image: http://v.youku.com/v_show/id_XNDkyNDY0MzIw.html
 said: http://weibo.com/1575142931/zb7hxcmjJ
 wrote: http://weibo.com/1617035897/zbfcqAexx
 法客瑾爷: http://weibo.com/1617035897/zbfcqAexx
 刘晓原律师: http://weibo.com/liuxiaoyuan2010
 东来和西去: http://weibo.com/u/1660360541
 扬尘无导: http://weibo.com/2159296617/zbmAGcVc8
 zhang3: https://twitter.com/idzhang3
 游离的世界已经灰白: http://weibo.com/n/%E6%B8%B8%E7%A6%BB%E7%9A%84%E4%B8%96%E7%95%8C%E5%B7%B2%E7%BB%8F%E7%81%B0%E7%99%BD
 游离的世界已经灰白: http://weibo.com/1968863541/zbf1Gg1Lw
 suggested: http://www.secretchina.com/news/12/12/25/479927.html?中国网络实名制即将立法(组图)&utm_campaign=KZG&utm_source=twitterfeed&utm_medium=twitter
Licensed Creative Commons Attribution, 2008 Global Voices Online. See attribution policy for details: http://globalvoicesonline.org/about/global-voices-attribution-policy