- Global Voices - http://globalvoicesonline.org -

Understanding the Violence in Western Myanmar

Written by Mong Palatino On 16 June 2012 @ 7:37 am | 17 Comments

In Citizen Media, East Asia, English, Feature, Governance, History, Human Rights, Humanitarian Response, Law, Migration & Immigration, Myanmar (Burma), Politics, Protest, Refugees, War & Conflict, Weblog

This post is part of our special coverage Myanmar's Rohingya [1].

Myanmar is in the headlines these days because of two things: the historic European visit of Nobel Peace prize winner Aung San Suu Kyi, and the violence [2] in Rakhine State located west of the country.

It’s difficult to blame a particular group for the riots [3], killings, and burning of houses that have taken place in the state in the past two weeks but the victims [4] were clearly ordinary Arakanese, the ethnic majority in the state, and the Rohingyas who are asking for recognition in Myanmar.

According to a government report, a total of 2,528 houses have been burnt down since the clashes started. Of these, 1,192 belonged to Arakanese and 1,336 belonged to Rohingyas. The report also mentioned that 29 people had died [5] in the fighting—13 Arakanese and 16 Rohingyas.

Thousands have been displaced [6] because of the communal violence. There are a total of 37 refugee camps housing 31,884 victims so far.

The Rohingyas are often described in the mainstream press and academe as the ‘most persecuted minority group in Asia.’ But opinion [7] in Myanmar is divided. In fact, the government doesn’t recognize the Rohingyas as among the country’s ethnic groups.

Aung Zaw [8], editor of the Irrawaddy, an alternative magazine, writes about the popular opinion against the Rohingyas

The consensus among Burmese, it seems, is that the Rohingya are illegal migrants from neighboring Bangladesh—a view that also treats this as an issue of sovereignty rather than religious animosity.

Indeed, many—especially ethnic Arakanese—have been resentful of the portrayal of this as a religious conflict, even though many have resorted to racial and religious slurs in their verbal attacks on the “Bengalis,” as they prefer to call the Rohingya.

…on the streets, popular opinion was more in favor of taking a hard line against the Rohingya.

Rohingyas are mostly Muslims which led many people outside Myanmar to ask if this is a case of religious persecution. But various religious organizations in Myanmar denied that it’s a religious issue [9]. They issued this declaration a few days ago

1. The conflicts in Rakhine did not begin as a consequence of religious strife, but because of the acts of breaking the prescribed laws.

2. All religious organizations in the Union of Myanmar have been co-existed with each other in harmony and in amicable ways for ages, and are still maintaining this good tradition

4. We vow to do our best in preventing the spread of this violence to other parts of Myanmar.

May Thingyan Hein [10] writes about the various conflicting perspectives regarding the riots in Rakhine

On the internet the unrests are viewed in different perspectives: one is that the government is playing a trick to disturb the people’s attention on them; the other one is that the government cooperated with Arakanese to eradicate Bengalis; and the last one is behind the sight the Rohingya are planning to cause uncertainty to the government and Daw Aung San Suu Kyi and ask their own autonomy in the area.

Kyaw Zwa Moe [11] blamed social media for fanning the flames of hate speech and racism

Why is it burning?

Media and social media [12], of course: Some internet users insensitively posted pictures of the initial slaughter on their Facebook accounts. These spread quickly and stirred other users to share emotional responses

Fortunately, there are moderate [13] online voices which have been actively calling for peace and unity. Dave Gilbert and Violet Cho posted some of the Facebook photos promoting harmony in the country

[13]

Photo from New Mandala

The Burmese caption reads:

‘All of us love our country. Let’s prevent the problems that are happening. Don’t make disagreements out of different beliefs. Leave people who want to go back to an earlier era so we will move on.’

[13]

Photo from New Mandala

Peace Warriors [14] are disturbed about the threat to harm Muslims in Yangon, the capital of Myanmar

“In papers distributed in Yangon for the past few days, people were urged to attack Muslims, their mosques, shops and houses. Muslim women were also singled out as targets. It has made Muslims and those of Indian descent afraid to go about their work, or to even go outside alone. Some Muslim families have closed their shops and Islamic Religious Schools and Universities closed two days ago”

State media New Light of Myanmar [15] reported the visit of government officials in refugee camps

As riots occurred in Rakhine State, local battalions arrived at the scenes to restore peace and stability and prevalence of law and order of the region and safeguard the life of the local people as of 8 June. Beginning that evening, the local battalions are providing necessary assistance to the local people. Moreover, some naval vessels are discharging duties of patrol to protect Myanmar waters territory west of Maungtaw not to be infiltration of unscrupulous persons.

Violet Cho [16] wants a more critical perspective in analyzing the situation in Rakhine

Poverty and state repression leads to intense frustration that does not have an easy outlet and can be seen as a common root cause of communal violence around the world.

If we dig below the surface, we can see that western Burma’s communal violence is rooted in wider and very complex historical, social, political, class and cultural processes. Perhaps we should start redefining outdated categories, such as race, and look through alternative lenses that can help lead to more productive analysis.

Human rights groups want Bangladesh and Myanmar to open their borders and accept Rohingyas who are fleeing from violence. Below is an appeal from the Asian Human Rights Commission [17]

…in order to enable the provision of adequate food and health services to the affected populations, both of your governments are requested to cooperate with one another so as to provide complete, unimpeded, secure access to international agencies at the earliest possible opportunity, in order that these agencies can assess the situation and make arrangements for the necessary provision of emergency relief supplies.

To the surprise of many activists and media people outside Myanmar, veteran officials of the opposition 8888 Generation Student Leaders [18] issued a statement which affirms the government line about the non-recognition of Rohingyas as citizens of Myanmar.

Ko Ko Gyi: Unless inevitable, we tried to avoid some issues patiently. Now it is time that we announce our view on Rohingya clearly. Rohingya is not one of the ethnic groups of Myanmar at all. We see that the riot happening currently in Buthedaung and Maungdaw of Arakan State is because of the illegal immigrants from Bangladesh called “Rohingya” and mischievous provocation of some international communities. Therefore, such interfering efforts by some powerful nations on this issue (Rohingya issue), without fully understanding the ethnic groups and other situations of Burma, will be viewed as offending the sovereignty of our nation.

Since no country wants to take them in, we feel sympathy for those people on the ground of humanity and refugee. Taking advantage of our kindness and deference, if the powerful countries forced us to take responsibility for this issue, we will never accept it.

Some activists are asking if Suu Kyi, who urged the application of rule of law [19] in resolving the issue in Rakhine, shares a similar position with the 8888 Generation Student Leaders.

The Myanmar government claims the situation is now under control in Rakhine. But the suffering in the villages of the Rohingyas continues to worsen everyday.

This post is part of our special coverage Myanmar's Rohingya [1].


Article printed from Global Voices: http://globalvoicesonline.org

URL to article: http://globalvoicesonline.org/2012/06/16/understanding-the-violence-in-western-myanmar/

URLs in this post:

[1] Myanmar's Rohingya: http://globalvoicesonline.org/specialcoverage/rohingya-myanmar-burma/

[2] violence: http://globalvoicesonline.org/2012/06/14/bangladesh-netizens-advocate-for-keeping-border-open-for-rohingya-refugees/

[3] riots: http://globalvoicesonline.org/2012/06/10/myanmar-rakhine-villages-attacked/

[4] victims: http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-asia-18395788

[5] died: http://www.irrawaddy.org/archives/6955

[6] displaced: http://www.mizzima.com/news/inside-burma/7325-31844-displaced-refugees-in-burmas-rakhine-state-minister.html

[7] opinion: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rHYvgnxuFuc

[8] Aung Zaw: http://www.irrawaddy.org/archives/6837

[9] religious issue: http://www.mmbreakingnews.com/?p=73

[10] May Thingyan Hein: https://www.facebook.com/note.php?saved&&note_id=450577478288810

[11] Kyaw Zwa Moe: http://www.irrawaddy.org/archives/6933

[12] Media and social media: http://www.dvb.no/news/internet-users-unload-anger-on-social-media-sites/22433

[13] moderate: http://asiapacific.anu.edu.au/newmandala/2012/06/15/voices-of-moderation-on-burmese-facebook/#more-19362

[14] Peace Warriors: http://seayouthsayso.com/activists-in-myanmar-calling-for-peace

[15] New Light of Myanmar: http://www.myanmar.com/newspaper/nlm/index.html

[16] Violet Cho: http://www.irrawaddy.org/archives/6696

[17] Asian Human Rights Commission: http://www.mizzima.com/edop/letters/7320-open-letter-to-burma-a-bangladesh-ahrc.html

[18] 8888 Generation Student Leaders: http://democracyforburma.wordpress.com/2012/06/12/8888-generation-student-leaders-ko-mya-ayeko-ko-gyi-min-ko-naing-spoke-on-bengali-rohingya-and-the-current-riots-in-burma-english/

[19] rule of law: http://www.dvb.no/news/suu-kyi-%E2%80%9Cwe-need-precise-laws-on-citizenship%E2%80%9D/22447

Licensed Creative Commons Attribution, 2008 Global Voices Online. See attribution policy for details: http://globalvoicesonline.org/about/global-voices-attribution-policy