- Global Voices - http://globalvoicesonline.org -
Hong Kong Rethinks its Relationship with Mainland China
Written by Andy Yee On 24 January 2012 @ 14:27 pm | 11 Comments
In China, Chinese, Citizen Media, Development, Economics & Business, English, Hong Kong (China), Migration & Immigration, Politics, Video, Weblog
2012 will see the 15th anniversary of the return of Hong Kong to mainland China. But Hong Kongers have little mood for celebration. A survey  conducted by the University of Hong Kong in December 2011, found that the number of respondents who view themselves as Hong Kongers is more than double the number who view themselves as Chinese.
Over the years, it has been a received wisdom that blessing from the mainland underpins the development of Hong Kong. This is most apparent when China’s support helped Hong Kong endure the 2003 SARS epidemic crisis and the 2009 global financial meltdown. However, after recent social and cultural clashes with the mainland, the Hong Kong public is now questioning that wisdom.
In January 2012, hundreds of Hong Kongers protested outside luxury store Dolce & Gabbana , which allowed mainland Chinese tourists but not local residents to take photos in front of the store. In a separate incident, disputes broke out between Hong Kong passengers and mainland tourists who ate on a train. It turned into a public fury when Peking University professor Kong Qingdong added fuel by saying that Hong Kong people are “running dogs ”.
In fact, in recent months, news headlines in Hong Kong are all about how mainlanders ‘invade’ the city. Local hospitals are stretched to the limits  as pregnant women from the mainland crossed the border to give birth with the hope of securing a Hong Kong passport for their offspring. Mainland buyers exhausted the Hong Kong baby milk powder market  amid food scandals in China. And as millions of Chinese tourists visit the city every year, it seems that all local residents could feel is their disregard of civic values and rule of law.
A view which is very common among mainlanders is that “without China’s economic support, Hong Kong would have been dead long ago.” But many Hong Kongers now think that the “mainland invasion” has done more harm than good to Hong Kong. Certain sectors, like retail, finance and real estate, have benefited greatly from mainlanders, but the inflation and housing bubbles created make the rest suffer. Furthermore, Hong Kong’s public system is yet to be prepared for a large influx of mainlanders. There is also a fear of the erosion of traditional Hong Kong values like the rule of law.
These views are now prevalent among Hong Kong bloggers and social critics. It is a complex challenge facing Hong Kong, one interlaced with local vs. mainland and poor vs. rich conflicts.
At Asia Sentinel, Alice Poon, a former real estate professional and author of Land and the Ruling Class in Hong Kong , explores  the value gap between mainland and Hong Kong, and the fact that only a narrow range of sectors could benefit from closer relationship with the mainland:
The unbridgeable gap seems to be between (Hong Kongers’) acceptance and (most mainlanders’) rejection of or aversion to universal values like rule of law, democracy, equality and liberty. It is not through the latter’s fault that they find these values alien; it’s just because they have been living under a political system that has infiltrated them with the idea that those are not Chinese values and therefore no good for them. The system has taught people that all they need worry about is the economy and how to make money and practically nothing else. Morals aren’t important. Corruption can be tolerated. There is of course no lack of intellectuals in China who have refused to be brainwashed and who truly embrace universal values, but most of them unfortunately are rewarded with either political exile or incarceration.
It goes without saying that the only Hong Kong people who welcome mainland tourists, immigrants and shoppers are developers and their cronies (real estate agents, contractors etc.), especially those who are large shopping mall landlords. Even for retailers, whether or not they can benefit from the influx depends on whether the products they sell are mainlanders’ favorites. As for the rest of Hong Kongers, all they can feel towards the swamping inflow is resentment.
Meanwhile, however, the influx of Chinese capitals and tourists could have some damaging long-term effects on Hong Kong’s economy. Stanley5’s Blog explains :
正正是因為「自由行」、中資企業來港上市，以及給境外人士投資地產 ，搞到香港白白失去產業轉型的機會。現在香港只有金融、地產與旅遊服務業，大量人才與資金被吸過去，地價租金又被推高，以至製造業消亡，其他產業也一蹶不振，就連我最愛的港產片也快要消失了。我經常說：論出口品牌，韓國有SAMSUNG，台灣有 HTC，新加坡也有CREATIVE，香港有什麼？山寨機？莎莎？屈臣氏？米蘭站？
但令我討厭的是，現在不少來自大陸的所謂「遊客」，其實並非來旅遊，也非欣賞香港，而是為了「辦貨」、帶水貨，賺兩地貨幣的匯率差價，還有不少人是挪用公款、洗黑錢 (例如 D&G 要保護的人)。但最難頂的是他們部分人的惡劣舉止與財大氣粗。你叫我要包容，我告訴你，他們很多人根本就沒有「自由行」的資格！
If the abundance of natural resources is an economic curse for some countries, the closeness to Chinese spending power is another form of curse for Hong Kong. Hong Kong has one of the highest levels of income inequality in the world. This is where you can find the world’s third-most expensive shopping strip , while over 100,000 people have to live in 6ft by 2ft “cage homes ”. As Hong Kong has gotten more and more wealthy, many local residents are left behind. Prominent social critic Leung Man To draws our attention  to the decline of Venice as an ominous warning for Hong Kong:
That being said, while Hong Kong could blame the mainland for all the social issues, it might have more to do with the policy failures of the Hong Kong government. In the opinion  of blogger Grey Reporter:
In the end, he hopes that ordinary Hong Kong people could realize the fact that they, like most mainlanders, live in an unjust political system under which the rich and the powerful collude. They share the same destiny, that is, to end this injustice:
Article printed from Global Voices: http://globalvoicesonline.org
URL to article: http://globalvoicesonline.org/2012/01/24/hong-kong-rethinks-its-relationship-with-mainland-china/
URLs in this post:
 survey: http://hkupop.hku.hk/english/popexpress/ethnic/eidentity/poll/datatables.html
 Image: http://globalvoicesonline.org/2012/01/24/hong-kong-rethinks-its-relationship-with-mainland-china/kong-qingdong/
 Dolce & Gabbana: http://globalvoicesonline.org/2012/01/09/hong-kong-flashmob-protest-against-a-luxury-brand-to-defend-local-identity/
 running dogs: http://globalvoicesonline.org/2012/01/20/china-and-hong-kong-train-scuffle-ignites-cross-border-fury/
 stretched to the limits: http://www.aljazeera.com/programmes/101east/2011/11/201111298154826963.html
 baby milk powder market: http://globalvoicesonline.org/2011/03/14/hong-kong-panic-over-milk-powder-shortage
 music video: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aWZFgkJNxDM
 Land and the Ruling Class in Hong Kong: http://www.asiasentinel.com/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=2628&Itemid=424
 explores: http://www.asiasentinel.com/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=4149&Itemid=334
 explains: http://stanley5.blogspot.com/2012/01/blog-post_22.html
 Image: http://globalvoicesonline.org/2012/01/24/hong-kong-rethinks-its-relationship-with-mainland-china/leung-man-to/
 third-most expensive shopping strip: http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2011-05-17/h-k-causeway-bay-shop-rents-set-to-soar.html
 cage homes: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2084971/Hong-Kongs-cage-homes-Tens-thousands-living-6ft-2ft-rabbit-hutches.html
 draws our attention: http://commentshk.blogspot.com/2012/01/blog-post_20.html
 opinion: http://greyreporter.wordpress.com/2012/01/21/populism-entrapment/
Licensed Creative Commons Attribution, 2008 Global Voices Online. See attribution policy for details: http://globalvoicesonline.org/about/global-voices-attribution-policy