North Korea: Two American Journalists Sentenced to Hard Labor

News coming out of Pyongyang is not encouraging. After being accused of illegally crossing the border to North Korea, American Current TV journalists Laura Ling and Euna Lee have been sentenced to 12 years of hard labor (according to CNN).  Jillian York rounded up blog posts for Global Voices prior to the journalists’ sentencing.

The bleak outcome is eliciting strong reactions online from those who support freedom of press and want North Korea to release the two journalists. A Facebook page for Laura and Euna already has more than five thousand members. Today they are asking the public to respect the families privacy at this moment and not to get emotional:

“You will have many emotions racing. Please try to stay clear of anger. Anger is a waste of energy and what North Korea wants of you.We can and will work together and use our minds, to work this through.”

LiberateLaura, a blog authored by Los Angeles entertainment journalist Richard Horgan, describes events happening in North Korea as “worthy of Shakespeare” and questions the decision of the “Hermit Kingdom” to arrest Laura Ling and Euna Lee:

“Unfortunately, into that mad kingdom, just ahead of the chaos, wandered @Current journalists Laura Ling and Euna Lee. On Tuesday, March 17th, whether by accident or the trickery of a paid-off Chinese guide, they are alleged to have stepped across an invisible border line at a bridge crossing between China and North Korea. Harsh interrogations and two and a half months of solitary confinement followed, and now, after a brief trial, an absurd sentence of 12 years of hard labor for illegally crossing the border and an unspecified “grave crime.”

The Shakespearean analogy is useful because it allows us, just slightly, to make sense of the unfathomable June 8th Ling-Lee verdict. Kim Jong-il is indeed pushing it to the limit on the diplomatic, nuclear and innocent Americans fronts, all in a bid to reassure the country’s military hard liners that a Kim Jong-un succession will maintain the Amy-first status quo.”

On YouTube, supporters are posting videos calling for the immediate release of Laura and Euna. There are also videos and photos of vigils in South Korea, San Fransisco and elsewhere in the United States.

Here is as public service announcement from Pacific Rim Video and Kelly Hu:

As the public and various organizations promoting free press are coming together to call for Laura and Euna's release, some are now questioning the reactions of United States State Department and former U.S. vice president Al Gore (the founder and chairman of Current TV, which employed Euna and Laura) to the situation.

At Asia Times, Donald Kirk says:

“The North Koreans also get offended every time a top-level American visitor visits the region, and one immediate complication of the trial is that it coincides with a trip to South Korea, China and Japan of a US delegation led by Deputy Secretary of State James Steinberg.

Steinberg has not talked publicly about the two women but has made clear in meetings with South Korea's President Lee Myung-bak and other top officials that the US is not willing to negotiate their fate. Could he have had their case in mind when he assured Lee that the US would not offer more aid for North Korea. “

He then proceeds to speculate about Al Gore's involvement in negotiations:

“How about giving them up to a high-level American delegation? Gore comes to mind as the man for the job in view of his control over the network for which the two women were working.

Gore has been strangely silent throughout, all the more reason to think he's waiting to give face to the North Koreans and rescue the two women – a happy ending that may be too much to hope for.”

Gore would be perfect for the mission. His presence would acknowledge North Korea's need for recognition as a member of the global nuclear club but would not constitute official US recognition of anything.

Not everyone is taking Gore's silence so lightly.  John in Condition Yellow takes Gore's lack of involvement less lightly, saying:

I don't expect Mr. Global Warming to just drop what he's doing and go sailing off to north Korea to negotiate the release of two people who work for him. The Nobel Peace Prize winner is far too busy saving the planet. Right? But how long would it take for him to issue a simple statement like, “Hey, Kim Jomg Il! Let my people go, or we will take your carbon credits away.”

But seriously, am I the only one who thinks that even a simple public statement from Mr. Pulitzer, condemning the trial, would at least be the decent thing to do for people who work for him?

Hmmm. Okay, maybe Bill Richardson would be more effective.

But one thing is for certain, as Jo points out in the blog Jo's Department – everyone is wishing for the journalists’ safe return:

I hope that they do not endure Pyongyang’s horrific (as described by escapees) prison system and that two journalists could safely return and be reunited to their families soon.

14 comments

  • I just found a new video on YouTube featuring a French film crew chatting with a young docent while touring inside North Korea’s Military Museum last month.
    The Frenchmen actually ask her about the 2 American journalists who were caught at the border with China and she seems to be saying that this is the first time she heard about such news!

    Here is the link:
    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5qe24PHFXq8

    The conversation about the 2 American journalists begins at 7:30 in the video and then later they joke about espionage. I’m sorry my French is not good enough to provide a professional translation, but maybe Global Voices Online can ask a European intern to translate the relevant material into English.

  • We continue our tour of the world media today with a quick glance at the latest headline involving the 2 American journalists in North Korea.

    Imagine you are a member of the Ling family and on Sunday morning begin your daily “Google news refresh” routine with Laura Ling’s name. The first article that actually pops up is a Portuguese headline from Brazil:

    “Uma sentença de morte”

    Perhaps nobody in Ling family studied Portuguese but the language does sound remarkably similar to Spanish, so it’s safe to assume that most residents of California will not have to resort to Babel Fish to translate the horrific headline as “A death sentence”

    Here is the 4th paragraph of the article, which details experiences in North Korean gulags, that finally mentions Laura Ling and Euna Lee:

    “Nos gulags, os prisioneiros sofrem todo tipo de abuso, e entre 20% e 25% deles morrem todos os anos. E é para onde irão as jornalistas americanas Laura Ling e Euna Lee – condenadas na segunda-feira a 12 anos de prisão por ultrapassarem a fronteira do país ilegalmente – caso não haja um acordo diplomático com os EUA.”

    http://zerohora.clicrbs.com.br/zerohora/jsp/default2.jsp?uf=1&local=1&source=a2544577.xml&template=3898.dwt&edition=12506&section=1014

    Here is my intern, Google Translate, with some quick help on the translation:

    “In gulags, prisoners suffer all kinds of abuse, and between 20% and 25% of them die every year. And that is where will be the American journalists Laura Ling and Euna Lee – on Monday sentenced to 12 years in prison for entering the country beyond the border illegally – unless there is a diplomatic agreement with the U.S.”

    The reason I bring this article to the attention of Global Voices Online is because I was going to beg the world’s media to be more “cautious about speculating” when writing articles (and headlines!). Most people who are referred to as North Korea “scholars, experts, and watchdogs” seriously doubt that the 2 Americans will actually stay in North Korea beyond Christmas. (Though why they choose a Christian holiday benchmark is beyond me.) Those same people also do not believe Laura and Euna will be asked to lift anything heavier than a folding chair, so the “hard labor” part of their sentence is not expected to occur either.

    12 years? Hard labor? Do you REALLY think the American journalists will serve the entire sentence and be given shovels to help dig the next nuclear bomb test site? I’m not worried about giving anybody in Pyongyang any funny ideas, but I am concerned that people in other countries around the world will have unnecessary nightmares after too much Googling of gulag reports.

  • Charlie

    Not siding with North Korea, but when an American breaks the rules, its hands down across the world for them. But everybody would be singing a different tune if it were two negros or arabs…

Join the conversation

Authors, please log in »

Guidelines

  • All comments are reviewed by a moderator. Do not submit your comment more than once or it may be identified as spam.
  • Please treat others with respect. Comments containing hate speech, obscenity, and personal attacks will not be approved.