Comments on: Nepal: Rumors Surrounding The Captured Mumbai Terrorist

By: The Dark Lord

The Dark Lord — Mon, 23 Mar 2009 06:20:05 +0000

The links linked to interesting pieces of articles.

By: Peace

Peace — Mon, 29 Dec 2008 03:17:07 +0000

well sarz , i am not sure who your father is but i would respect him for framing such a great constitution, but unfortunately he would be turning and tossing in his grave if he hears what you say.

Conspiracy theories are great my friend, but it just wouldnt happen in our country and you know why?. Its the same constitution that we are talking about. The four pillars of our democracy are so independent that any such thing would be out in the floodlights the moment it happens

and coming to the reason why i called your statements ” hamid gul” mentality. he is an unbearded terrorist, who created taliban and who believes that 9/11 was work of zionists. and he is liar of the first order. i dont have the link now but when you get time, try listen to his interview with fareed zakaria of CNN and you will feel pity for pakistan who had generals like this.

By: Diganta

Diganta — Sat, 27 Dec 2008 06:10:28 +0000

To sarz,
For a change, I would like to ask you one more question. what would have happened if there were no Ajmal Kasav caught – rather we would have killed all ten of them. It’s only by chance that we got hold of one of them, otherwise you could have thought many more things that incidentally you don’t … It may happen that you don’t care for proofs as all proofs can be fabricated.

By: Diganta

Diganta — Sat, 27 Dec 2008 05:52:02 +0000

To sarz,
It does not matter which country you belong to or what your views are on imperialism. Only facts do count here.

To engage in a constructive dialog about 26/11 attacks, you need to first think about the evidences those already have surfaced. Let me remind you that there are four independent resouces those points out the history of Ajmal Kasav. Now, what is your explanation on all four of those? So far, I didn’t see any of the conspiracy theorists are doing a good job on this.

The links you have provided me so far, all of them points out a lot of ‘gap’s in the information acquired by public and investigating agencies (26/11->Police). All Investigation Agencies of the world does not work to answer “all” the queries (though ideally that would have been the best one), because they have limited resources to work with. To answer all questions, they will take much longer time and it would defeat the purpose of the investigation. That’s why they aim at a probabilistic approach to solve the case and leaves a lot of ‘gap’s.

By: diganta

diganta — Sat, 27 Dec 2008 05:36:15 +0000

To sarz,
It does not matter which country you live in nor are your views against imperialism. These does not affect the facts.

If you really want to discuss about what I claim conspiracy theories, you first need to come up with an alternative explanation of Geo News clips and the Dawn newspaper editorial. So far, conspiracy theorists are not doing very well on that front. Remember, there are four INDEPENDENT resources those point to the same – Ajmal Kasav is from Pakistan. You need to explain all four of them.

I went to the links you have given me. They do provide me a list of “unexplained” things. But, I understand that all Investigation agencies work on limited resources and capabilities. If they want to answer all (impossible?) queries of everybody, they would take a huge amount of time that would defeat the purpose of investigation itself.

To let me believe in an alternative, I did not see any real alternative story being put down by the theorists. Also, what proof they get in favor of their version of story – is also missing. Have you really thought about those?

By: diganta

diganta — Sat, 27 Dec 2008 05:23:36 +0000

To sarz,
It does not matter where are you from and what do you think about Imperialism. what matters is whether you are able to bring up sufficient evidences against the existing proof – Ajmal Kasav is from Pakistan and was trained by LeT to strike India. The Geo news clips and the Dawn Editorial suggests that and Govt of Pakistan did not take any steps against either of these two. Hence, it’s crystal clear what the truth is. If you want to question the official version, you have to first explain what is been shown in Geo News and what has been written on Dawn editorial. Do you have any explanation for them? If yes, then I would like to discuss, otherwise, I won’t.

The investigation agencies do not require to answer every question that is being asked by citizens. They have limited resources and hence they work on specific targets. Most of the people take chances on the ‘gap’s left by them to prove their point. However, absence of proper answer does not establish a theory contrary to the proofs given. So, you can present a thousand loopholes in the news media reports, but no theory is established until you rubbish the proves that are available.

By: sarz

sarz — Thu, 25 Dec 2008 18:46:47 +0000

To “Peace”. My country happens to be India and I am the son of one of the framers of the Indian Constitution. I am horrified to see my country being hijacked by sinister forces of Western imperialism and the well-placed Indians who are willing to serve them. As for Hamid Gul, I do not know why you are mentioning him, but let me mention an interview he did with Alex Jones, the independent American journalist, which I am sure will be of interest to readers of this site. The address is http://rss.nfowars.net/20081209_Tue_Alex.mp3

By: neeraj sharma

neeraj sharma — Thu, 25 Dec 2008 07:59:25 +0000

When India Knows that Pakistan canot be trusted and many Pakistani Organisations are supported by Pak Govt and loved by pakistanis, why does India believe Pakistan. It is no secret that they hate us from depth of their heart but we go on hoping that one day wisdom will descend on them and they would realise their mistakes. The day will come when they strike India with N bomb and India hardly in a position to reply back. No wonder Indians have remained under foreign rule for 1000 years.

By: Peace

Peace — Thu, 25 Dec 2008 02:17:50 +0000

Sarz, i really pity your knowledge and your ” Gen Hamid Gul” mentality. God save your country Pak if you guys continue to live in a delussionary world.

By: sarz

sarz — Wed, 24 Dec 2008 17:04:11 +0000

Dear Diganta, or whoever is writing under that name. Of course you do. You already have. Your point was to argue for the Indian government’s story (theory) of the conspiracy that shook Mumbai. Do look up the word in a dictionary. It comes from ‘con’ meaning ‘together’ ‘aspire’ meaning ‘to breathe’ and ‘to hope’ — the word denotes people acting together to plan a crime or to commit one. Or are you suggesting that governments never lie about these sorts of things in order to go to war? If so, there is an educational treat in store for you. All you have to do is take a look at the website How 9/11 Was Done. At how911wasdone.blogspot.com . The same people probably did Mumbai. To get a better sense of the global background, I highly recommend the article “Creating an ‘Arc of Crisis’: The Destabilization of the Middle East and Central Asia – The Mumbai Attacks and the ‘Strategy of Tension’” by Professor Andrew G Marshall. Here is the link: http://www.globalresearch.ca/index.php?context=viewArticle&code=MAR20081206&articleId=11313 . If the link does not show here, go to the website of globalresearch.ca , and look up the articles under the name Marshall.

By: Diganta

Diganta — Tue, 23 Dec 2008 22:15:27 +0000

I don’t want to discuss conspiracy theories. Please …

By: sarz

sarz — Mon, 22 Dec 2008 18:13:40 +0000

Diganta, thanks for your response. I have checked out your two links and they confirm what you say. It is said Kasab used to come once a year, that he came last a couple of months ago for Eid, that he showed his karate prowess and that he is reported to have asked for his mother’s blessings for a jihad he was going to undertake. While this does militate against the lawyer C M Farooque’s claim that Kasab was abducted by Indian forces in 2005, one would still like to know whether there was an application with the Nepali Supreme Court in February 2008 and letters to the Indian high commission and Nepali forces. Terror attacks of this sort are more likely false flag operations than what they seem on the face of it. We now know this about 9/11. There were no Muslims involved. It does sound outlandish, but there is enough clear evidence to back the claim. Check out how911wasdone.blogspot.com/ . It was a Zionist operation, with US government support. There are indications that the same forces are behind Mumbai. We can now see that In 9/11 the methods used were unusual and cutting edge. So we cannot rule out the possibility of Kasab being abducted and then ‘turned’, like in the CIA’s M K Ultra program. Google CIA, MK Ultra . There are many oddities to Kasab’s treatment after capture. The Indian authorities first showed him on TV, on the verge of death it was said, and only allowed to speak for five minutes at a time. But then the dean of the hospital said he was not wounded at all. Later we were told he had been shot in the palms of the hands. An unwounded Kasab would lead to a lot of questions. Maybe he was shot in the palms later. The only other witness to the Karkare murder, police inspector Jadhav, has a quite fantastic story to tell as well. And he also has some cosmetic wounds. Karkare’s autopsy has been delayed way past the sell-by date. His body was cremated before the report was released. Antulay’s question has thrown the Indian establishment into disarray. So if this event has not been done by the same forces who carried out 9/11, with the co-ordination and blessings of the BJP and the Indian government, in order to break up Pakistan, it will take a lot of tying up of loose ends to establish the fact. In the meantime, the lead question is, Who benefits? It is not Pakistan. It is Western, Zionist-controlled imperialism, and it is, at least in the imagination of many of its leaders, India.

By: Diganta

Diganta — Mon, 22 Dec 2008 05:11:47 +0000

Please see the Geo News clips here :
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HJWiztYjO70

The villagers say that he came back a few months back and showed his Karate power.

This report confirms another independent report by Saeed Shah (this happens to be the first one on the case) who said that Kasav used to return once in a year.

http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2008/dec/07/mumbai-terrorism-india-pakistan

By: Nepal News archive for 17 December 2008 - Latest Nepal News and Headlines

Nepal News archive for 17 December 2008 - Latest Nepal News and Headlines — Wed, 17 Dec 2008 15:10:03 +0000

[...] Rumors Surrounding The Captured Mumbai Terrorist – Global Voices Online.org (December 15, 2008) – [read more]Regions and Countries Â» Americas Â» Central Asia & Caucasus Â» East Asia Â» Eastern [...]

By: sarz

sarz — Wed, 17 Dec 2008 07:21:30 +0000

Diganta, I have tried to check out your story. The Dawn of December 12, that finally confirms that Kasab belongs to Faridkot and contains a statement of acknowledgment by his father, says that he disappeared four years ago. Please give the sources you claim from Dawn and Geo. Until then, other readers should be cautious until they find independent confirmation of your claims regarding his recent visit to his village.